June 23.
Wolfseye Members: Quade, Heath, Mulvenon, Pritchard
Evaluation: Which Wolfseye Brew is the best (the age old question)?
Criteria: Each member was asked to compile a list of the five best Wolfseye brews. The batches were then assigned points based on their appearance on these lists (5 pts for top of the list, 1 pt for bottom).
Winners:
#5 Rikki Tikki Tavi India Pale Ale (tops on two ballots)
#13 Ira Hayes American Indian Pale Ale
#10 Old Bolshie Amber Ale
Scores:
#5 Rikki Tikki Tavi India Pale Ale -- 13 pts
#13 Ira Hayes American Indian Pale Ale -- 11 pts
#10 Old Bolshie Amber Ale -- 6 pts
#6 Von Stauffenberg's Assassinator Dopplebock -- 6 pts
#3 Old Bolshie Amber Ale -- 4 pts
#4 George Orwell Nut Brown Ale -- 4 pts
#7 Nietzsche's (So) Bitter -- 4 pts
#9 Doc Holliday's California Common (Steam) Beer -- 3pts
#10A Old Bolshie Amber Ale -- 3 pts
#14 Marquis de Sade's Old Speckled Cock -- 3 pts
#1 George Orwell Nut Brown Ale -- 2 pts
#15 Nietzsche's (So) Bitter - 1 pt
Worth Consideration:
If the Old Bolshie Amber Ale scores are added (batches 3,10,10A), then it equals the 13 points of the I.P.A.
Same calculations can be run on George Orwell Nut Brown Ale (batches 1,4,11) and Nietzsche's (So) Bitter (batches 7,15) to get a good read on collective members' tastes.
#2 Iron Drawers Honey Porter is generally accepted by the collective members as a good brew - it doesn't appear on our list more due to style preferences.
I think #13 Ira Hayes American Indian Pale Ale was overlooked by some members (James). As well as it did, it could have done better. I also believe #14 Marquis de Sade's Old Speckled Cock may make a run up the leader board as we begin to really enjoy it - it's not sexy but it's good.
Watch out for #12 Groundskeeper Willie's Wee Heavy - it will tear down the wall...